[POLL] Best FoG Logo Contest #3

. . .

Best FoG Logo Contest #3
Thread can be found here: Link
This poll will close on 11-10.2016 at 22:13 - Be advised that this is a public poll: other users can see the choice(s) you selected.

. . .





. . .​

Contestants & Entries:
KvistKJW - Entry [Link]

Spoiler

Koga73 - Entry [Link]

Spoiler

Judges:
75% of the Points will be givin by a judge for: Creativity, Effort, Design, Beauty.
Judges will give a score from [0-5 points] for each of the 4 categories before the deadline [11-10/16].

The last 25% will be given by a public poll.


Prizes:
[table="width: 700, class: grid, align: center"]
[tr]
[td]1st place
1 Month VIP
Gold Contest Badge on profile
50 Forum Reputation Points
Name in the Hall of Fame
Banner/Logo presenting the Community[/td]
[td]2nd place
Silver Contest Badge on profile
30 Forum Reputation Points
Name in the Hall of Fame[/td]
[td]3rd place
Bronze Contest Badge on profile
15 Forum Reputation Points
Name in the Hall of Fame[/td]
[/tr]
[/table]
​

Please read: Information
Contestants may vote, but not on their own entry.


Friendly reminder to the Judges: @Yoda @Fahlo

 

I dislike both.

 

Added option for keeping the current logo/banner in the POLL.

 

You've forgot one mate

 

Aight lets get to it:

Ranking from 0-5 in the categorys Creativity, Effort, Design a Beauty.

Koga73:

Spoiler

Creativity: 3
A fancy F that looks like a 7 is.. yeah. Though there is potential with the shield for a tiny logo.
Effort: 3
Well nothing astonishing in using a font
Design: 4
Considering that the shield along with the letters to use it as a Logo for promotions, etc. is pretty alright.
Beauty: 4
Pretty simple and appealing. At least in my eyes.

Total: 14
Still needs some tweaking, though it's cool looking.

KvistKJW:

Spoiler

Creativity: 4
Overall a very nice idea.
Effort: 3
The actual effort isnt that big. Considering that coming up with the logo is the biggest part, making the letters with a font and adding effects isn't that much.
Design: 2
Just not that mindblowing to be honest.
Beauty: 3
Nothing big to say. Pretty colors and effects. Thats it though.

Total: 12
Very nice submission. I like it, though on second thought I don't think it's very suitable for a logo.

Old logo:

Spoiler

Creativity: 0
Use the logo from the game we are hosting.. Yea very original
Effort: 1
At least the color was changed.
Design: 0
No.
Beauty: 2
Works, I guess. Nothing ugly.

Total: 3
Since we are not only a TF2 but also a CS:GO community now we should definitely change it up. This logo was never really amazing in my eyes.

Changes NEED to be made, even if people don't like it. They will get used to it, just like with the rank colors. ("BUT I DIDN'T" yea shut up)
This current logo is bad at representing our community as a whole. It's time for a change.

 

Changes NEED to be made, even if people don't like it. They will get used to it, just like with the rank colors. ("BUT I DIDN'T" yea shut up)
This current logo is bad at representing our community as a whole. It's time for a change.

 

I do have to agree with you that it is not very original/authentic.

 

Looking for a new judge to replace @TheBluekr

 

Sure, I can take over

 

I've talked to @Fahlo who will be taking over as a Judge. Thank you anyways

 

Koga:
Creativity: 4
Effort: 3
Design: 4
Beauty: 4
Simple with a personal touch, a bit like the current one, and that's what I like. Nice and simple.

Kvist:
Creativity: 4
Effort: 5
Design: 3
Beauty: 3
Very artistic and pretty, but I dislike the fact that it says Fortress OF gamers, in those capitals. Otherwise it looks quite shiny and nice.

Old logo:
Creativity: 1
Effort: 2
Design: 3
Beauty: 3
Very simple. The negative isn't that it's bad, it's that it's too simple. I would prefer a new and improved logo.

 

Just thought I'd ask if this is acceptable or not..

 

Then this should be even more "not-accepted".
Looks like a bigger ripoff than a letter.

 

yea, no

 

What's the point, keep the old logo and problem solved.

 

Hate to say it, but for a simplistic design and to keep everyone happy, Spindel's in discord might be the pick.

 

The F is a font by itself. And it isn't stolen from that logo, obviously not the same.

Edit: http://www.dafont.com/marguerite3.font?text=F&back=top

 

Locking thread for now.